Have Customers across States? Here’s how GST will Affect you

Last updated on July 17th, 2017 at 12:08 am

The ultimate dream of every business is growth and expansion. One starts a business, earns profit, re-invests, earns more profit – and the cycle continues. You get your first customer, then 10, then 100. You start off in your immediate locality, and as you grow, you expand your operations to your city, your state, neighbouring states – till the entire country is your playground.

However, in the current taxation regime, this is easier said than done. Apart from the obvious finances and efforts that businesses with customers in multiple states invest, there are also a fair amount of compliance costs and complications which are incurred – both by seller and buyer.

Selling Goods to Customers in Other States

Current Regime GST Regime
The Centre levies Central Sales Tax (CST) on interstate sales, which is collected and retained by the state from where the sale has happened. IGST will be levied on interstate sales. Here, the incidence of the taxation shifts from “sale” to “supply”.
Once the goods crosses state borders, it is subject to verifications and checks at border check posts. Further, entry taxes are levied, which is borne by the buyer i.e., your customer. Once the goods reach and cross state borders – there will be relatively less verifications and checks, and no entry tax will be charged. This will reduce the price for the buyer i.e., your customer.
When you make an interstate sale to your B2B customer, the CST charged is a cost to him. This is because – when he in turn, makes a local sale, he cannot claim tax credit for the CST he has paid. Consequently, he passes on the value of CST paid to his end customers – for whom the cost of goods increases. Thus, both you and your customer, are at a competitive disadvantage compared to those dealers who procure locally, and thus, can offer goods at a lower price. Your B2B customer will be able to claim credit of the IGST charged on interstate sales and set-off the same against his GST liability towards the State in the order prescribed by the Law. Thus, he will not incur any additional cost, and this will eventually reduce the cost for his end customers. Thus, you will not be at any disadvantage when compared to local dealers, and can compete with them with ease.
To maintain their competitive prices, most interstate sellers set up branches/warehouse in the states where they generally operate – so that their buyers need not bear the brunt of CST. However for the seller, it means extra infrastructure cost, and that too, this cost is incurred more for the purpose of compliance rather than operational efficiency. Selling from another state and selling within the state, both will be equally conducive to the buyer due to seamless availability of input credit. Hence the seller need not invest in excess infrastructure, just for compliance – rather, he can now decide to set up branches/warehouses for the sole purpose of operational efficiency.
Illustration

Ram Enterprises is a dealer of shoes in Uttar Pradesh selling to a dealer in Karnataka

Before GST
When Ram Enterprises raises the invoice:

  • Product Price = INR 5000
  • CST @ 2% = INR 100
  • Final Price = INR 5000 + 100 = INR 5100

In addition, the dealer in Karnataka needs to bear entry tax @ 2% (average rates for footwear in Karnataka) = INR 102

Total cost to the dealer in Karnataka = INR 5100 + INR 102 = INR 5202

When the dealer in Karnataka sells to an end customer locally, he will sell the shoes at INR 5202 + profits + applicable taxes (since credit of CST and entry tax is not allowed, and that is passed on to the end customer).

Under GST
When Ram Enterprises raises the invoice:

  • Product Price = INR 5000
  • IGST @ 18% = INR 900
  • Final Price = INR 5000 + INR 900 = INR 5900

When the dealer in Karnataka sells to an end customer locally, he will sell the shoes at INR 5000 + profits + applicable taxes (since credit of IGST is allowed, and is not passed on to the end customer).

Thus, GST will surely simplify the compliance processes for interstate sales of goods, and prove to be a boost. First of all, the input tax credit chain will remain uninterrupted on interstate transactions, leading to elimination of the cascading effect – thus, benefitting both seller and buyer. However, to ensure that this entire cycle flows smoothly, the GST law stipulates a compulsory GST registration for all dealers making taxable interstate supplies, irrespective of threshold limit. In other words, composition scheme will not be an option for interstate sellers.

Supplying Services to Customers in Other States

In the current regime, Service Tax is levied on the interstate supplies of services. Service Tax is levied and collected by the centre, and thus the registration for the same is also unified and central.

In the GST regime, with goods and services facing the same treatment, IGST will be applicable when there is an inter-state supply of services. However, the complication lies somewhere else – in the GST regime, the taxation is dependent on place of supply of services. Thus, if you being a service provider, are providing services from your state to a client in a different state – IGST will be applicable. However, if the type of service requires your presence at the location of the client itself i.e. at the state of the client, it will be treated as an intra-state supply of service; in other words SGST/UTGST and CGST will be applicable and not IGST. And for that to happen, you will need to take registration in the state of the client.

Illustration

Consider a CA Mr. Prasad, who is registered at New Delhi, but also having clients at Gurugram (Haryana) and Noida (Uttar Pradesh) – since all 3 cities are part of the National Capital Region and are extremely close to each other.
To his Client 1 based out of Gurugram in Haryana, he provides consultancy services remotely.

To his Client 2 based out of Noida in UP, he provides internal audit services, for which he visits the client and provides services by travelling to client’s location.

Before GST
Selling goods to customers across states before GST

In this scenario, there is only one unified, central registration for service tax, irrespective of the fact that he is providing services across 2 or 3 states. Also, in the current regime, Mr. Prasad needs to file returns under service tax only 2 times a year.

Under GST
Selling Goods to Customers in Other States_2

Under GST, Mr. Prasad, is liable to file returns 13 times a year (including annual returns) – for his registered location at his home state i.e. Delhi. But now, if he wishes to provide services to clients in Gurugram and Noida via physical presence – he will now need to, not only take registration under Haryana and UP, but file 39 returns in the year! Thus, with GST coming in, all service providers will have to face a trade-off – revenue flowing in from clients across multiple states, versus, the corresponding compliance burden in terms of multiple registrations and multiple filings.

The Final Say

In conclusion, selling goods or supplying services to customers in other states – does seem like a mixed bag. While the situation is definitely better for interstate sales of goods – with state barriers potentially dissolving and free-flowing credit for businesses – the situation is exactly the opposite when it comes to supply of services. Under GST, all service providers will now have to move from a centralized registration to a state-wise registration – if they wish to continue providing services via physical presence in all states where they have clients. Another potential roadblock is the inability to use the CGST + SGST / UTGST credit accumulated in one state against the CGST + SGST / UTGST liability of another state – which is bound to impact cash outflow.

So, while GST surely intends to provide a multitude of benefits in the long run, it does however come along with a bagful of challenges, which need to be tolerated and addressed for the greater good.

 

Are you GST ready yet?

Get ready for GST with Tally.ERP 9 Release 6

About the author

Pugal T & Pramit Pratim Ghosh

41 Comments

  • Mera retail cloth matching and tailoring met.items shop hai than se cutt karke ham 2.50 cmt. Kapda cut ke diya uski value 500/= 5% g s t 550 /= ka hamne billing ki maal delhi se liya faridabad Haryana me shop threads 5% needles 12% jiska ham tax paid ka bill lhete dhe aab kese hoga saal 4 lakh total purchase thi taxable goods kisi leeye s t number nahi liya

  • Reg. Services provided to Customer in another State : What if the Customer is GST Registered ?
    I think , in that case even if the service is given with a Physical presence, being given to a Registered Person it will attract IGST & not SGST+CGST
    Pl. advise

  • Thanks tally to educate about GST.
    Please let me know the tax rate for unstitched textile clothes (like salwar,sarees,dhotis…)& nonbranded stitched items (like shirts,nighties,inskirts…)

  • Services are the most revenue generating stream in current system, however there seems to be bigger headache in GST scheme of things.
    Should govt not devise another mode to address this crucial needs. For cross border events there is IGST why can’t the services be treated as one be it physical / virtual….should service industry not represent the case with the GST council….after all GST is for people and it should be simple not complex one like taking registration – 29 at present…..may be if new states carve out in future then its even more bad.
    All this will lead to people to find some workaround and defeat the very purpose the GST – “one nation one tax”

    • ONE NATION ENDLESS REGISTRATIONS AND FILING OF IGST RETURNS….haw haw haw…ACCOUNTANTS need to be paid a salary of min Rs.1 lac per month…see how ONE NATION ONE TAX has SIMPLIFIED LIFE OF BUSINESSMEN…a vast BLANK AREA between what the Bhajap claims an what in reality it is…nightmare for Business…

  • There appears to be some mistake in sale price under GST in the above example.dealer cannot sell to end consumer without adding igst/sgst/cgst.what is the use of credit of GST if not charged from consumer.

    • Think it’s by oversight. What would have been meant is Rs. 5000 + Profits + CGST/SGST @ 9% each which gets set off partly by ITC claimed under IGST paid earlier.

    • Thanks for your comment! Yes, the Karnataka dealer will be charging 5000 + profit + applicable taxes. The essence here was to point out that the final price will be on the transaction value itself, and not tax on tax. However, the same has been updated in the blog. Thanks for pointing it out!

  • With reference to the para –
    “When the dealer in Karnataka sells to an end customer locally, he will sell the shoes at INR 5000 + profits (since credit of IGST is allowed, and is not passed on to the end customer).”

    How can the dealer sell at 5000+profits? Isn’t GST going to be collected on the final sale value by dealer? If not, against what liability will he adjust the 900 credit in electronic ledger if he is not supposed to collect and pay any tax on retail sale? And, if the credit indeed cannot be adjusted against any liability, it effectively becomes a cost for the dealer since he will pay the 900 to his supplier, and yet again he can’t sell a shoe costing 5900 at 5000+profit.

      • For the dealer in Karnataka, the product price is 5,000 + Profit. When making a supply, he will charge 5,000 + Profit + CGST & SGST/ IGST, as applicable.

        • “When the dealer in Karnataka sells to an end customer locally, he will sell the shoes at INR 5000 + profits (since credit of IGST is allowed, and is not passed on to the end customer)” This what you have given in the article.You had not referred the taxes CGST/SGST there…if a mistake is occurred it is desirable to admit it..

          • Thanks for your comment! Yes, the Karnataka dealer will be charging 5000 + profit + applicable taxes. The essence here was to point out that the final price will be on the transaction value itself, and not tax on tax. However, the same has been updated in the blog. Thanks for pointing it out!

  • Sir, tally solution rise there price too much after 31st march; is this justified. if you make your rates reasoanable then your competitors dont take chance to capture market. now a lot of companies are there in market who proposed low rates.

    • Thanks for your comment! However, would like to bring to your notice, that there is no increase in price – the only change made is from a tax inclusive price to a tax exclusive price. Since you will be buying Tally software for furtherance of business, you will be able to avail full input tax credit on the same, once GST comes in.

  • In the above illustration under GST, it was wrongly mentioned CGST+IGST for CGST+SGST in the case of CA taking registration in UP and provides services to client2.

© Tally Solutions Pvt. Ltd. All rights reserved - 2017